Okay, first let me be perfectly clear, I hate cover songs and what I hate even more are crappy pop songs. And let that exactly be what Rhapsodies In Black is, covers of crappy pop songs. Still I am very happy to write this review. Why you might think? Well because it’s absolutely phenomenal what these ladies are doing, which is making a powerful metal song of a well-known pop song without changing it unrecognizably. Yeah sure, that’s fun and all, just put some heavy guitars and a double bass drum under it and you got some metal. If that was all that these ladies are doing then it wouldn’t be very exciting, but this supergroup consisting of Clementine Delauney, Amanda Somerville, Maria La Torraca and Anna Brunner packs some punch. It’s clear that this group of top vocalists aren’t meant to be questioned by me as a reviewer or anyone else regarding their vocal capabilities, because damn, these women can sing. Take for instance Rihanna’s Unfaithful, it is absolutely unbelievable what happens to this song when it’s being sung by people who can actually sing. The Backstreet Boys’ Incomplete suddenly becomes a very good song with some simple changes and some folk influences, this is mainly due to the variable vocal styles of the leading ladies.
But is it really metal? Well, these songs are written as pop songs, even when they are sung by Exit Eden. The band did show me the potential of a great and well thought of pop song. When you give the song just little bit more care, it becomes a song that you wanna put on over and over again. For example, Frozen by Madonna, I myself never thought it was a bad song but wow, what a song it became! Very cool!
So, can I say that I like covers now? Sadly no. Because it on itself beautiful enough Heaven by Bryan Adams loses all of its emotional baggage and warmth due to Exit Eden’s treatment. No, the ladies don’t sing the song in a bad way, but saying it kindly, it’s a very weird choice to put on the album and it should’ve been left alone! Thankfully the rest of the choices are really good. Especially Lady Gaga’s Paparazzi and Bonnie Tyler’s Total Eclipse Of The Heart. These two songs have been turned into full-blown metal songs!
Rhapsodies In Black if you ask me, is for anybody who knows in their heart that pop songs aren’t bad but can be a whole lot better. And of course, it’s also for people who just love good music.
Thanks Exit Eden!